Everyone likes a delightful dish of broiled meat and vegetables. You get to enjoy a good meal without having to deal with excess fats. All that wouldn’t be possible without the best nonstick broiler pan.
Broiling meat is synonymous with lots of fat. And if one thing’s for sure, nobody likes cleaning grease of their kitchenware. Lucky for us, broiler pan manufacturers got wind of this and started manufacturing nonstick broiler pans.
Broiler pans are available everywhere. Just a simple search on your favorite online shopping platform will generate hundreds of results. The same applies to shopping physically. The choices out there are simply overwhelming.
Eight Best Broiler Pans in market
So, how can you ensure that you choose the best one? The most straightforward answer here is through lots of research and countless hours evaluating every product individually. So, to ease your shopping experience up a bit, we reviewed eight of the best nonstick broiler pans on the market. We’ve also thrown in a few factors to consider when selecting the best one.
| SL | Product Name | Weight | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Whirlpool Broiler Pan and Grid | 3 pounds | Check Price |
| #2 | Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan | 2.9 pounds | Check Price |
| #3 | Range Kleen Broil and Bake Pan | 1 pounds | Check Price |
| #4 | Frigidaire Oven Broiler Pan | 2.5 pounds | Check Price |
| #5 | GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan | 0.16 ounces | Check Price |
| #6 | Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler | 9.6 ounces | Check Price |
| #7 | USA Pan Nonstick Cooling Rack | —– | Check Price |
| #8 | Norpro Broil/Roast Pan Set | 1.31 pounds | Check Price |
After thorough research and going through tons of products, we managed to come up with this list of eight broiler pans on the market.
Best non stick Broiler Pan Reviews
1. Whirlpool Broiler Pan and Grid
One of the most notable things about cooking with porcelain is that it doesn’t break or warp, even in high temperatures. The Whirlpool 4396923 comes in a lovely and durable finish that is sure to complement the aesthetic appeal of your kitchenware collection.
This broiler pan is specially designed to provide you with an even cook. So that your food turns up exactly as intended. And if you have a Whirlpool then you’re in luck because this broiler pan is compatible with most Whirlpool ovens out there.
Its nonstick surface makes it super easy to clean and maintain. It is also constructed from high-quality materials. So you don’t have to worry about breaking it that easily.
Pros
- Durable finish
- Easy to clean
- Compatible with most Whirlpool ovens
- It is factory-certified
Cons
- This pan might warp when subjected to very high temperatures.
2. Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan
The Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan give you a perfect blend of quality, durability, and affordability. This three-piece set is made of porcelain and a carbon steel core for additional energy efficiency and heat distribution.
The porcelain enamel provides superior nonstick and non-porous qualities to ease you when cooking and cleaning it. And in case you’re worried about the nonstick coating poisoning your food, don’t be. The nonstick coating on this broiler pan is PFOA and PTFE-free.
At 15.81 x 10.06 x 2.88 inches, this broiler pan can fit in most ovens. And its ability to heat up quickly and retain the heat allows for an even cook, with minimal browning.
Pros
- Affordable
- Great design
- Impressive dripping system
- Excellent heat retention
- Even heat distribution
Cons
- It is quite hard to clean the grease off of it.
3. Range Kleen Broil and Bake Pan
If you are looking for a broiler pan that will give you unmatched value, versatility, and durability. This might just be the product for you.
This pan is made from heavy-duty porcelain with a steel grill and base. The heavy-duty porcelain construction makes it very resilient. It is also dishwasher-safe.
In terms of versatility, you’ll like the fact that due to its convenient size and materials. This broiler pan is compatible with most toaster ovens and outdoor grills. It is also ideal for baking cakes, lasagne, desserts, and practically anything else you can think of.
Pros
- Made of high-quality, durable materials
- Dishwasher safe
- It comes in a convenient size
- Easy to clean
Cons
- The pan tends to discolor after repeated use.
4. Frigidaire Oven Broiler Pan
If you’re looking for a replacement broiler pan for your Frigidaire stove, this might be a perfect fit. But, you might want to confirm its compatibility before purchasing it.
This broiler pan is also compatible with a wide range of ovens out there. So, as long as you have about 15.8 x 12.6 x 2.3 inches worth of space in your oven, you’re good to go.
This pan features a large broiler pan with a tray that provides an even cook for a wide variety of dishes.
Pros
- Genuine replacement part
- Easy to clean
- Durable
- Easy to use
Cons
- It does not fit in all Frigidaire ovens.
5. GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan
If you are looking for a fine pan that caters to the broiling needs of a big family. Then the GE WB48X10056 might just be the product for you.
This fairly large pan is suitable for anyone who owns a GE oven. Although it was originally meant as a replacement part, it is also compatible with most ovens and outdoor grills out there.
This broiler pan comes equipped with a rack that makes broiling and roasting a whole lot easier. It also comes equipped with vents that help in even heat distribution.
The porcelain coating gives it a stylish look that is sure to complement the aesthetic appeal of your kitchenware. Also making it very easy to clean and maintain.
Pros
- Affordable
- Durable
- Easy to clean
- Excellent heat distribution
Cons
- The edges on this broiler pan are a bit sharp and could cut your hands if you don’t handle it correctly.
6. Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler
If you are looking for a small pan to handle small meals. You should check out the Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler.
Despite its small size, this broiler pan is made from high-quality materials. It can easily handle extreme cooking temperatures. It,s steel core and porcelain enamel ensure even heat distribution for a perfect cook and also makes it pretty easy to clean.
Its small size makes it perfect for toasters and small ovens. It can also fit easily into any oven or kitchen drawer. The removable rack also comes as an added convenience when roasting.
Pros
- Nonstick pan
- Ideal for toasters and small ovens
- Easy to clean
- Removable rack
Cons
- The nonstick coating is not very durable.
7. USA Pan Nonstick Cooling Rack
If you are looking for a nonstick broiler pan alternative that will offer you all the benefits of a broiler pan at a fraction of the price? Then this could be the pan for you.
Measuring an outstanding 16.75 x 11.5 x 0.5 inches, it can allow you to broil lots of meat and vegetables simultaneously. So, if you cook for a large group of people, it might come in handy.
This rack features a tight cross-wire design that adds to its classic look. It also comes equipped with six feet raised feet for added ground clearance and stability.
The patented Americoat nonstick coating allows for a comfortable cook and an even easier cleaning experience. With some warm water and soap, you can get it back t its shiny condition, no matter what you cooked.
Pros
- Affordable
- Can broil lots of food simultaneously
- Nonstick surface
- High-quality construction
Cons
- The pan warps when heated in extremely high temperatures for too long.
8. Norpro Broil/Roast Pan Set
One of the biggest issues facing broiler pans is warping. Now, what if you had one that didn’t warp, even in very high temperatures? Check out the Norpro Broil pan.
Unlike our previous picks, this is not a nonstick broiler pan. But, it offers the same benefits, not to mention its impressive durability and efficiency. Its stainless steel construction can withstand high cooking temperatures. Its unique design facilitates seamless food release.
The diamond pierced diamond perforations on its metal rack allow fats and juices to sip easily to the collection pan underneath. This helping you enjoy less greasy, healthy meals.
Pros
- Durable
- Excellent heat distribution
- Dishwasher safe
- It comes with a separate roasting tray
Cons
- It doesn’t come equipped with a nonstick covering.
Our Top Pick
As our top pick, we chose the Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid. Although it was originally meant as a replacement broiler for Whirlpool ovens. This pan is also compatible with most similarly-sized ovens out there.
One of the things we enjoyed about it, its superior heat distribution ability when compared to other similarly-priced pans. It also has an impressive anti-warping ability when subjected o high cooking temperatures. And considering its affordable price, I’d say it’s a pretty good take.
Best Broiler Pan – Buying Guide
1. Size
This is probably the most important factor you’ll have to consider before choosing pan for your kitchen. After all, you don’t want to reach home only to figure out that your new broiler pan can’t fit in your oven, do you?
You should, therefore, go for a broiler pan that fits in your oven perfectly. If your oven’s shape is rectangular, then you should go for a rectangular broiler pan. The same applies to circular and oval-shaped ovens.
You should also measure the internal dimensions of your oven to ensure you get a broiler pan of the right size.
2. Material
When it comes to the best broil pans, construction material makes all the difference in terms of functionality and efficiency. Different materials react diffidently to heat. Some materials are better compared to others in terms of heat retention and distribution.
If you buy a broiler pan made of low/poor-quality materials, you might end up wasting a lot of energy cooking. And the chances are that your meal might also come out ruined.
Some materials are also harder to clean than others. And when you’re dealing with cookware that’s going to be constantly covered with grease, you have to consider its ease of cleaning.
The most popular broiler pan construction materials are stainless steel, ceramic, carbon steel, and cast iron.
3. What food are you planning on cooking with it?
Broiler pans are made with a particular type of food in mind. Most traditional broiler pans were made for cooking steaks, but modern pans can cook a wide variety of meals.
Therefore, when shopping for a broiler pan, look for one that has the ability to cook the kind of food you like. For example, if you like roasting your meat, you might consider getting a broiler pan made of stainless steel. Likewise, if your recipe mainly involves foods that require even heat distribution, then a broiler pan made of cast iron might be your best option.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are broiler pans safe to place in the dishwasher?
The most straightforward answer here is yes. Most of them are safe to use in the dishwasher. That said, broiler pans with a nonstick surface are NOT safe when using the dishwasher. On the upside, these types of pans don’t require much cleaning since food doesn’t stick on them.
Can broiler pans be used for baking?
Yes, you can use a broiler pan for baking. But, you might also have to use an oven-safe baking sheet with it.
What other option can I use if I don’t have a broiler pan?
If you don’t own a broiler pan, you can use an aluminum foil tray, baking tray, or the cast iron pan.
Can a broiler pan cook bacon?
Yes. But, in order to use your broiler pan for cooking bacon, you’ll need to use aluminum foil. First, wrap the bacon inside the aluminum foil and place your broiler pan in your oven between the racks. You should aim to place it just at the middle, neither too high nor too low.
After about five minutes, remove the bacon, flip it, then broil it for another two minutes, and you’re done!
Can I use a broiler pan for roasting?
Most broiler pans don’t have racks high enough to facilitate roasting. But, those that come equipped with a rack to collect juices can be used for roasting. Therefore, just make sure your broiler pan’s rack is high enough to collect all juices to prevent a messy roast.
What way is best when cleaning a broiler pan?
Cleaning a broiler pan all comes down to removing the grease. You can remove sticky food and grease by soaking the pan in hot, soapy water.
For an even better clean, you can add a cup of ammonia to the mixture. However, don’t mix ammonia with any bleach since it might produce harmful gases. Then, leave it soaking for about 30 minutes.
If your broiler pan is covered with a thick layer of grease or other stubborn baked-on foods, heat it in the oven until it’s very hot. Next, set it over the sink and mix two spoonfuls of sugar into a cup of apple cider vinegar and smear the mixture over the pan.
After about an hour, wipe off the mixture and start scrubbing. Scrubbing will remove most of the mess, but wash the pan in a mixture of hot, soapy water to err on the safe side. When washing, avoid using any abrasive cleaners. Instead, go for a plastic scraper or mildly abrasive sponge.
You can also use the self-clean option in your oven. You should, however, check the oven’s operating manual to ensure that it is safe. Before starting the self-cleaning action, wash most of the grease off to avoid any fire hazards, then follow the self-cleaning procedure in your owner’s manual. After cleaning, let the oven and pan cool before removing it.
Conclusion
Broiler pans have been around for decades. Each decade brings with it new broiler pan technology that seems to make them even better and more efficient.
In the article, we have reviewed some of the best broiler pans on the market. These broiler pans meet both the safety and efficiency standards expected in a high-quality broiler pan.
Before you go out shopping for a broiler pan, make sure you go through our buyers’ guide section. That way, you will be better suited to make a good choice.
We’ve also answered some of the questions that might have been on your mind. But in case of any further questions, feel free to let us know. Good luck, and happy shopping!